Unsolved Case Files Harmony Ashcroft Review: Is It Worth It?

Updated October 2026

If you are wondering whether Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft is worth buying, this spoiler-free review covers exactly what it is like to play, how difficult it is, how many people can play and whether it is good value.

We played the Harmony Ashcroft case around our own kitchen table after enjoying the Jamie Banks game, and it quickly became one of our favourite family mystery games. It feels much more like opening a real cold case file than sitting down with a traditional board game.

Affiliate disclosure: This post contains Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only ever recommend products we’ve personally tried and genuinely enjoyed.

Harmony Ashcroft at a glance

Here’s a quick cheat-sheet if you’re just after the headline details before diving into the full review:

What is the Unsolved Case Files Game Harmony Ashcroft?

According to the publisher, Goliath Games, this is a cold case murder mystery game in which you play the role of a detective reopening a 1998 case.

The scenario is fictional but feels strikingly real, set in the small town of Riverdale, Indiana, you’re handed the original investigator’s file and tasked with solving three linked mysteries to crack everything wide open.

Harmony was murdered in the parking lot behind a local restaurant the night before her wedding. A local vagrant called Bones McBride was convicted and has now spent over two decades behind bars, except he’s completely innocent. Your job is to prove it, dismantle the real killer’s alibi, and find the single piece of evidence that will finally put them away.

Who are the suspects?

Without giving anything away, there are four main people to investigate as you work through the case:

• Christian Peterson — Harmony’s fiancé, who argued with her on the night she died and was the last person seen alone with her.
• Derek Sivers — a war veteran with a strong reason to resent Harmony after her court testimony affected his family life.
• Andy Allen — Harmony’s lifelong best friend, whose feelings for her were more complicated than they first appear.
• Rex Ratliff — an unsettling stalker who refused to leave her alone.

Every one of them has a motive, and every one of them gives you something to question.

Working out who is telling the truth, who is hiding something and which details actually matter is what makes the case so gripping.

What’s inside the case file?

TThe presentation is one of the best things about this game.

The case arrives in a sealed evidence file that you physically have to open before you can start, which immediately makes it feel more like an investigation than a standard board game.

Inside, you get more than 50 pieces of evidence, including:

• newspaper clippings
• police reports and investigation notes
• crime scene photographs
• witness statements and interview transcripts
• a coroner’s report
• fingerprint cards
• phone records
• sealed envelopes containing extra evidence and new objectives

Nothing feels thrown in just to bulk out the box.

You end up spreading documents across the table, comparing timelines, checking small details and debating which pieces of evidence actually matter.

That realism is what makes Harmony Ashcroft feel so immersive.

How Do You Play Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft?

The game is split into three objectives that you work through one at a time.

You begin by investigating the original case and trying to prove that the man convicted of Harmony’s murder could not have committed the crime.

From there, you work through more evidence, challenge alibis and eventually try to identify the key piece of evidence that solves the case.

After each objective, you use the official Unsolved Case Files website to check your answer.

If you are correct, you can move on to the next stage.

If you are wrong, you simply keep investigating. The game does not immediately spoil the solution, and there are hints available if you get completely stuck.

There is no timer, no complicated setup and no need for batteries.

You just open the file, spread the evidence out and start investigating.

Is the game hard?

We found Harmony Ashcroft challenging enough to stay interesting without becoming frustrating.

There is a lot of evidence to work through, but the real challenge is deciding which details are important and which are simply background information.

If you get stuck, the official online system gives you hints without immediately revealing the full answer.

I would describe the difficulty as moderate.

It is clever enough to make you feel very pleased with yourself when something clicks, but you do not need to be Poirot to get through it!

How long does it take to solve?

You are looking at roughly 90 minutes to three hours, depending on how many people are playing and how deeply you analyse the evidence.

With two people discussing every clue and going backwards and forwards through the documents, ours took closer to the three-hour mark.

That actually made it feel like really good value because it filled an entire evening.

A larger group may move through the case more quickly simply because there are more people reading and spotting details at the same time.

How many people can play?

Harmony Ashcroft can be played by 1 to 8 people, but from our experience, around 2 to 6 players feels like the sweet spot.

You can absolutely play it solo if you enjoy working through puzzles and true-crime-style cases on your own.

Personally, I think the game is at its best when you have someone else to bounce theories off.

Half the fun is confidently accusing the wrong person while somebody else points out the clue you completely missed.

If you have a larger group, you could even split into teams and see who cracks the case first.

What age is it suitable for?

The official age recommendation is 14+.

The story centres around a murder, so the theme is naturally quite dark, but the evidence is more about documents, photographs and deduction than anything graphic.

There is nothing especially gory in the box.

It can work really well for families with older teens because everyone has something to read, compare and discuss.

It is also a brilliant option for a screen-free evening. If you are looking for more easy family activities, my no-prep indoor activities for families guide has more ideas.

Is Harmony Ashcroft Based on a True Story?

No.

Despite how realistic the case file feels, Harmony Ashcroft is completely fictional.

The documents, photographs and evidence are designed to look authentic, which is why it feels so convincing while you are playing.

For me, that actually makes the game easier to enjoy because you get the fun of solving a cold case without dealing with the uncomfortable side of turning a real victim’s story into entertainment.

How does it compare to other games in the series?

Harmony Ashcroft was the first case released in the Unsolved Case Files series and it is still the one I would recommend as a starting point.

The difficulty feels well balanced and the case itself has a strong mix of documents, motives, timelines and physical evidence.

We also played the Unsolved Case Files Jamie Banks game afterwards.

Jamie Banks feels a little more modern, while Harmony Ashcroft has more of a classic cold-case feel because the story is set in the late 1990s.

Both are good, but if you are completely new to the series, I would start with Harmony.

There are now lots of other cases available too, so if you enjoy the format, it is very easy to disappear down the rabbit hole and end up with another file waiting for the next rainy weekend.

Who will love this game?

IThis game is especially good for:

• true crime fans
• couples looking for a different date-night idea
• families with teenagers
• groups of friends
• puzzle and escape-room fans
• anyone who enjoys detective stories
• people who are awkward to buy gifts for

It works well because it does not feel like a traditional board game.

There is no board, no dice and very little setup.

You are simply handed a pile of evidence and told to solve the case.

Does it make a good gift?

Yes, definitely.

It is one of those presents that feels a little different from the usual board game or puzzle book.

It works particularly well for teenagers, couples and anyone who already enjoys true crime, escape rooms or murder mystery games.

The packaging also looks great as a gift because it genuinely resembles an evidence file.

And because it can be played solo or with other people, the recipient does not need to organise an entire group before they can use it.

Is Unsolved Case Files: Harmony Ashcroft Worth It?

For us, yes.

The strongest part of Harmony Ashcroft is how immersive it feels.

What We Loved

• the realistic evidence-file presentation
• lots of documents and clues to work through
• clever puzzles without becoming frustrating
• online answer checking without instant spoilers
• works well solo, as a couple or in a group
• excellent for a full evening of entertainment
• easy to set up and start playing

Things to Know Before You Buy

• once you know the solution, you cannot properly replay the same case yourself
• you need internet access to check your answers
• it is not a quick 20-minute game
• you need enough table space to spread the evidence out properly

None of those were deal-breakers for us.

If anything, the fact that it takes a good chunk of an evening is part of the appeal.

Is Harmony Ashcroft Scary or Gory?

No.

The theme is dark because it is a murder mystery, but the game relies on documents, photographs and deduction rather than graphic imagery.

We did not find anything in the box particularly disturbing.

What Is the Best Unsolved Case Files Game to Start With?

We would start with Harmony Ashcroft.

It was the first game in the series and, from the cases we have played, it has a really good balance of challenge and accessibility for newcomers.

It gives you a clear idea of how the format works without being too easy or ridiculously difficult.

The Bottom Line

If you have been looking at Harmony Ashcroft and wondering whether it lives up to the hype, we think it does.

It is clever, immersive, well presented and excellent value for an evening of entertainment.

We have recommended it to plenty of friends since playing, and it is exactly the kind of game that gets everyone talking around the table.

The only question left is whether you can work out who killed Harmony Ashcroft.